Hunting for Wild Menu Options
Not since Sonic All-Stars Racing er, Sonic Racing All-Stars? ... Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed have my attempts to use a game's multiplayer features been so absolutely confounded.
First, each of my co-op buddies and myself had to - separately - play enough of the Monster Hunter Wilds campaign to enable multiplayer. This took about an hour's worth of cinematic cutscenes, non-interactive story scenes, combat tutorials, a boss battle, MORE cutscenes, MORE non-interactive story scenes; it was a whole "thing." And an ambiguous thing to boot, only documented in fan-written guides.
Next we had to try and parse all the different forms of multiplayer, which are ... a lot. It turns out that creating a Lobby, giving that Lobby ID to friends, and asking them to join that Lobby, only brings friends into your Base Camp -- not quests or out-of-camp gameplay.
Inviting friends into a Link Party only enables chat features -- still no gameplay.
Now, within a Link Party, creating an "Environment Link" shares the world outside Base Camp with you and your friends; but not in story quests. In fact, Environment Link blocks everyone in it from starting a new quest, until and unless one leaves the Environment Link.
The feature that finally achieves multiplayer co-operative quests is - starting with an existing Lobby or Link Party (but not an Environment Link!) - Joining Another Player's Quest. One player must start the quest solo, and then other players can join the in-progress quest.
I'm not even going to bother detailing the UI hell of nested menus involved in these options. It's, well, wild.
Of course... you can only join another player's active quest if your own story progress has unlocked that quest, or if you've already done it.
Also, not all quests are joinable, only ones with combat. Most narrative-focused quests - like NPC conversations or traveling to a new map - cannot be joined by another player (but are still blocked by an Environment Link).
So to recap, you can't play together from the start; you can only play together in certain quests; and you must have a quest unlocked to join it. Meaning that the only way to play through the story "together" is for everyone to do non-multiplayer story sequences separately, then join up for share-able hunting quests, then break for the next story sequence, and so on.
But my anguish regarding its impenetrable multiplayer is only part of why I lost interest in Monster Hunter Wilds. Fact is, the gameplay itself (with or without friends) is absolutely not for me.
Early combat is incredibly tedious: monsters take so much damage, and require so much repetitive chasing, I felt bored more than anything else. And with all the resource-collection and equipment-upgrade mechanics that NPCs keep yammering on about, I can tell that the path forward is just going to be more of the same with bigger numbers.
Approaching Monster Hunter Wilds as a co-op friendslop-ey experience didn't work, but I don't think that's because Capcom failed to implement fun multiplayer features. I mean, they did fail, but I don't think they were aiming for a full co-op experience in the first place.
I think they might've been aiming for an experience that existing Monster Hunter fans, who've been grinding through gear upgrades in repetitive hunting missions for 20 years already, and who might actually understand the game's labyrinth of menus, could play and replay together.
Whether their fanbase considers this a success, or not, I couldn't say. I'm not in it.